Seminole Wind
By Bobby Neal Winters
I was out on my walk today listening to music. John Anderson’s song “Seminole Wind” came up on my playlist.
So blow, blow Seminole wind,//
Blow like you're never gonna blow again.//
I'm calling to you like a long lost friend //
But I know who you are.
I wondered to myself whether this was cultural appropriation.
Cultural appropriation. I’ve learned a lot of new phrases. Cultural appropriation; colonization; ethnic cleansing.
I hear these. I think about them. I try to do it with a fair mind. I try to reflect.
That word reflect is a good one. I try to mentally look in the mirror and see if any of that reflects back on me.
As many of you might know, I am from Oklahoma. Oklahoma is a Choctaw word that means “red people.” It is one way the indigenous people referred to themselves. The indigenous people were a part of our lives in that part of the country in the way they aren’t here in Kansas.
We (my brother and I) grew up learning about the “Civilized Tribes”--a label that is not necessarily embraced by those to whom it refers--like frogs learn about water. They were simply a part of the world we lived in. We learned to name the tribes in this order: Chickasaw, Choctaw, Cherokee, Creek, and Seminole. The sports teams in the town of Seminole, Oklahoma, had a cheer that went: “Chickasaw, Choctaw, Cherokee, Creek, Seminole, Seminole can’t be beat.”
But, as I said, they don’t necessarily embrace the name “Civilized Tribes.” One commonality they do have is they were removed forcibly from their land in the eastern part of the United States. They weren’t hurting anyone, they weren’t threatening anyone. They were on land that could be used to raise cotton on; cotton prices were good; they were removed so others could take their land and--with the aid of slave-labor--grow cotton.
There was money to be made from the cotton, money to be made from the slaves. So they were moved to Oklahoma on what has come to be known as the “Trail of Tears.” I am not quite sure that this necessarily meets the requirements to be called “Ethnic Cleansing,” but it sure smells the same.
This was done by Andrew Jackson against the decision of the Supreme Court of the United States. Jackson is famously quoted as saying, “The Court has made its decision, now let them enforce it.”
They couldn’t; it wasn’t; an atrocity was committed.
They lost their homes in Mississippi, Alabama, and the Carolinas. They had to go to Oklahoma. Whatever the merits of the Great State of Oklahoma, it would be traumatizing to be forcefully moved from anywhere to anywhere else.
Home is home.
We can’t even use the excuse we were Christianizing them.
One reason tribes of the Trail of Tears were referred to as “Civilized” is that they were already Christians, Baptists and Methodists for the most part. And I say Christian, but many of the missionaries marveled at how readily the indigenous peoples took to Christianity. Read this as they were better Christians than the Christians the Europeans knew. One can still see this in how they take care of their people using that casino money.
The Trail of Tears is one of our country’s sins. Just one.
It’s a sin. But it’s a sin that some of us (many of us; most of us?) have profited from.
How do we deal with this? At church on a weekly basis, I stand with the rest of my church and confess to a litany of sins and the minister says, “In the name of Jesus Christ, you are forgiven.”
Do we as a country need to confess to a litany of sins and beg forgiveness in this way?
Not this way. But in some way.
We need to study our history through a clear lens, not rosy, not dark. We need to recognize where we erred, but we also need to recognize that sometimes all of the choices available are bad ones.
My way is to write about it. If some of you didn’t know about the Trail of Tears, you do now. The United States--WE--broke our own laws. Can we make up for it? I seriously doubt it. But we can remember it:
So blow, blow Seminole wind,
Blow like you're never gonna blow again.
I'm calling to you like a long lost friend
But I know who you are.
And blow, blow from the Okeechobee,
All the way up to Micanopy.
Blow across the home of the Seminole,
The alligators and the gar.
Bobby Winters, a native of Harden City, Oklahoma, blogs at redneckmath.blogspot.com and okieinexile.blogspot.com. He invites you to “like” the National Association of Lawn Mowers on Facebook. Search for him by name on YouTube.